Choosing the right suitcase can make your travels smoother, faster, and a lot less stressful. Whether you’re flying once a year or every week, the wrong bag can mean struggles at the gate, broken zippers mid-trip, or endless frustration with wobbly wheels.
After reading hundreds of real traveler reviews including advice from flight attendants and pilots on Reddit’s r/BuyItForLife — we’ve narrowed it down to five carry-on and check-in suitcases for 2025 that combine durability, functionality, and value. These are the bags travelers trust to last for years, not just a few trips.
TSA locks, Expandable, Spinner wheels, Durable shell
Multiple compartments, Expandable, Lightweight, Affordable
Crushproof, Watertight, Customizable interior, Carry-on approved
USB port, Integrated suiter, Expandable, Trusted by flight crews
Lifetime repairs, Premium build, Expansion system, Smooth wheels
How to Choose the Right Suitcase in 2025
If you’re a frequent flyer, durability should be at the top of your list. Many Reddit travelers swear by Samsonite, Travelpro, and Briggs & Riley for their ability to survive years of baggage handling without breaking down. Casual travelers may care more about weight, style, and how easily a bag fits into overhead bins.
Other important factors include warranty, internal organization, and expandability. Frequent business travelers might prioritize built-in USB charging, wrinkle-free suiters, or lifetime repair guarantees, while vacationers may be fine with something budget-friendly yet reliable.
Best Carry-On & Check-In Luggage for 2025
- 1. Samsonite Freeform 23-Inch Hardside Carry-On – Best Lightweight Hardshell
- 2. SwissGear Sion Softside Expandable Luggage – 21-Inch – Best Budget Softside
- 3. Pelican Air 1535 Case – No Foam – Best for Fragile Gear
- 4. Travelpro Platinum Elite Softside Expandable – 21-Inch – Best for Frequent Flyers
- 5. Briggs & Riley Essential 22" Expandable Spinner – Best Lifetime Warranty
1. Samsonite Freeform 23-Inch Hardside Carry-On
The Samsonite Freeform is consistently praised by travelers for its lightweight yet highly durable hardshell. On Reddit, several users mentioned using their Samsonite for nearly a decade without major damage, even with frequent check-ins.
It features TSA-approved locks, smooth spinner wheels, and an expandable design for extra capacity. Its sleek style and airline-friendly dimensions make it a versatile option for both carry-on and occasional check-in use.
Reasons To Buy:
- Lightweight hardshell with TSA locks
- Expandable for extra packing space
- Smooth-rolling spinner wheels
- Proven long-term reliability
Reasons To Aviod:
- Limited external storage
- Glossy surface can show scratches
2. SwissGear Sion Softside Expandable Luggage – 21-Inch
For those who prefer the flexibility of a softside suitcase, the SwissGear Sion offers excellent value. Reddit users recommend it for casual travelers who want something affordable yet functional, especially for weekend getaways.
It includes multiple compartments, an expandable zipper, and reinforced corners to handle wear and tear. While it’s not as indestructible as premium models, it offers solid performance at a budget-friendly price.
Reasons To Buy:
- Affordable with solid construction
- Multiple organizational compartments
- Expandable for extra space
- Lightweight and easy to handle
Reasons To Aviod:
- Not as durable as higher-end options
- Zippers could be smoother
3. Pelican Air 1535 Case – No Foam
Designed for travelers carrying fragile or expensive gear, the Pelican Air 1535 is practically indestructible. On Reddit, some compared it to a “tank” thanks to its crushproof, watertight build that protects your belongings no matter how rough the journey.
It’s airline carry-on approved and can be customized with dividers or foam inserts. While heavier than a typical suitcase, it’s the top choice for photographers, filmmakers, or anyone traveling with sensitive equipment.
Reasons To Buy:
- Crushproof and watertight construction
- Lifetime durability
- Carry-on size approved for most airlines
- Customizable interiors
Reasons To Aviod:
- Heavier than standard luggage
- Limited internal pockets unless customized
4. Travelpro Platinum Elite Softside Expandable – 21-Inch
Travelpro is a favorite among flight crews, and the Platinum Elite series shows why. It’s lightweight, easy to maneuver, and packed with features — including a built-in USB port and an integrated suiter for wrinkle-free clothes.
Its expandable design, premium wheels, and solid zippers make it ideal for frequent business or leisure travel. While pricier than entry-level bags, its comfort and reliability make it a long-term investment.
Reasons To Buy:
- Lightweight and smooth maneuverability
- USB charging port
- Multiple compartments for organized packing
- Trusted by flight attendants and pilots
Reasons To Aviod:
- Higher price than budget luggage
- Fabric can stain if not handled carefully
5. Briggs & Riley Essential 22" Expandable Spinner
Considered by many travelers the gold standard of luggage, Briggs & Riley is famous for its unconditional lifetime warranty — if it breaks, they fix it. This 22″ spinner offers premium materials, a unique expansion-compression system, and self-repairing zippers.
It’s heavier and pricier than most competitors, but for travelers who want one suitcase to last decades, it’s worth the investment.
Reasons To Buy:
- Lifetime repair guarantee
- Premium build quality and materials
- Smooth, sturdy spinner wheels
- Innovative expansion system
Reasons To Aviod:
- Very expensive compared to others
- Slightly heavier than mid-range models
Final Overview: Which One Should You Choose?
If you’re on a budget, the SwissGear Sion or Samsonite Freeform offer great value without sacrificing performance. If durability is your priority, the Pelican Air 1535 is unbeatable. Frequent flyers will appreciate the comfort and features of the Travelpro Platinum Elite, while those seeking a long-term investment should look no further than Briggs & Riley.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What size suitcase is best for international flights?
Most airlines limit carry-ons to 22” in height (including wheels and handles). Always check your airline’s specific size rules before traveling.
2. Is hardshell or softside better?
Hardshell is better for protecting fragile items, while softside offers more flexibility and external storage options.
3. How long should a suitcase last?
With proper care, mid-range luggage can last 5–10 years. Premium models like Briggs & Riley can last decades thanks to repair programs.
4. Are expensive suitcases worth it?
If you travel frequently, investing in a high-quality suitcase can save money in the long run by avoiding replacements and repairs.
